Sunday 15 May 2011

The Help - Book Review

Here's the second of my book reviews, also published on www.creaturesofculture.com. Looking forward to the film coming out this summer...


The Help by Kathryn Stockett


After reading The Help, you will be unable to divorce the words ‘Jackson, Mississippi, 1962’ from notions of racial discrimination, and all that this entails. Kathryn Stockett chooses to set her novel in a milieu predicated on the racial divides between white families and their black maids, at a time when the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was beginning to gain momentum. In doing so, she delves into a seriously controversial, taboo subject of modern American history, predominantly using a black voice. This may seem like an ambitious ploy in the debut novel of a white woman who grew up in Jackson, but Stockett pulls it off incredibly well. The result is a beautifully written novel in its most human form, simultaneously heart-warming and heartbreaking. 



Stockett takes a three-pronged approach to the narrative: the story unfolds through the eyes of Aibileen and Minny, two black maids who work for ladies from the cream of white society, and Miss Skeeter, the 23-year-old daughter of a cotton plantation owner and seemingly a pillar of this segregated community. Aibileen, raising her seventeenth white child and nursing the pain caused by her own son’s tragic death, is a model of obedience and submission, whilst Minny’s sassy tongue earns her continual dismissals, and leads her to do a ‘Terrible Awful Thing’ to one of her previous employers. Skeeter, so called because of ‘mosquito-thin’ looks she had as a child, is desperate to be a writer. Longing to discover what has become of her own cherished maid who has disappeared, she hits upon the idea of collating stories that the domestic maids of Jackson have of working for white Southern families. Thus our unlikely trio is brought together by the compulsion to voice previously silenced tales and by the subsequent consequences of this radical and controversial act.

Interestingly, those most alienated in this novel are actually white: Miss Skeeter lives just outside of town, reflecting her status as an outsider from the white circle of friends dominated by the chief baddie, Miss Hilly; Celia Foote, a pink and fluffy delight, lives in an isolated area and, too poor to be prejudiced, is eschewed by the white women because she married Miss Hilly’s ex-boyfriend. Their ultimate alienation exemplifies what happens to enemies of the society’s ringleader, regardless of race. Whilst the black community has an indomitable sense of solidarity, the white community is fickle, where ‘friends’ come and go: Miss Skeeter is a shining example of this. The Benefit that Miss Hilly organises for the ‘Poor Starving Children of Africa’ (despite victimising the Poor African-Americans of Jackson) is Stockett’s critique of this hypocrisy and is arguably still relevant today: how often are our heads turned by a well-publicised disaster and subsequent charity, thereby ignoring the problems under our own noses?

Skeeter (Emma Stone) with her friends in the upcoming film adaptation

In spite of the serious subject matter with no easy resolutions,
The Help is immensely readable because it is peppered with light-hearted images: there is a farcical image of Miss Hilly’s garden overflowing with toilets, and it is surely no coincidence that Aibileen’s neighbour is called Ida Peek (‘I had a peek’). This is fundamentally a novel about women; men remain distanced and largely two-dimensional. Minny in particular rises out gloriously: her exterior toughness masks an interior vulnerability that comes from an abusive alcoholic husband. It is when she, our strongest character, frees herself that we see a metaphorical glimmer of hope for future freedom. The Help is a compelling read and a novel to cherish.

Friday 13 May 2011

Book review numéro un: Mornings in Jenin

A while ago I began doing what my good friend, Anna, described as 'getting back onto my creative bicycle'. In other words, keeping up my literary pursuits. Being a book worm, I thought the best way for me to begin remembering how to ride my 'bike of creativity' (oh Anna, your analogies) would be to write book reviews. This blog begins its life as a compilation of these reviews...



And voilà, here is the first of them. To be totally honest, I chose this book for the very reason that you should never choose a book: because of the front cover. I don’t know why, but I was intrigued by the face of the little girl peering around the big wooden door (and, I guiltily admit, where was Jenin?!) Although it took me a while to get into this book, having started it in less than ideal circumstances on the train home on a Friday night, I’m glad I finally did. It’s a good book, well written, and I learned a lot about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It has also been published on the cultural review website, Creatures of Culture (www.creaturesofculture.com - check it out!!) Enjoy...

Mornings in Jenin by Susan Abulhawa

Mornings in Jenin, originally entitled The Scar of David, is not for the faint of heart. Susan Abulhawa wields a persuasive pen of anguish, brutality and destruction to force us to take a fresh look at one of the most tenacious and defining political conflicts of our time. A thought-provoking, moving and extremely powerful testimony to the Palestinian plight, it exposes the fragility of humanity in times of upheaval.

The story begins in Palestine, 1941. The Abulheja family are at home in the small, tranquil village of Ein Hod. It is ‘a distant time, before history marched over the hills and shattered present and future’: a balmy era of ripe fruit, marriages and harvests that will of course serve as a sharp contrast to the
devastation that is to come.


Sure enough, el nakba, the catastrophe of 1948, quickly unfolds. Israeli soldiers descend upon Ein Hod, forcibly removing its villagers and sending them to a refugee camp in Jenin. A mother has her six-month old son snatched from her arms by an Israeli soldier, who gives the child to his wife, a survivor of the Holocaust. The boy, renamed David, is raised an Israeli and unknowingly becomes an enemy soldier to his own blood brother who loses everything in the struggle for freedom. Yet Abulhawa chooses not to focus her story on what could be an original cross-faith narrative of these brothers’ conflicting perspectives. Instead, the story is exclusively Palestine’s, as events unfold through the eyes of these boys’ younger sister, Amal.

Born and raised in the refugee camp, Amal is injured by shrapnel in the 1967 war, leaving her physically and emotionally scarred. It is as painful to witness the continual dashing of her hope for her father’s return, as it is to see her disown her mother who has been left mentally vacant by the war. Orphaned, she moves to boarding school in Jerusalem where she meets friends who ‘shared everything from clothes to heartaches’ and then finds herself alienated and alone in the United States. On a visit to her brother in Lebanon she marries a Palestinian doctor and we have a momentary glimmer of hope of new beginnings as she becomes pregnant. Yet again her losses accrue once she is back in the cocoon of America, a helpless witness to the atrocities in her homeland.

It may at times feels as though Abulhawa is laying it on a touch thick; she extracts horrific eyewitness accounts from real sources giving the novel a documentary quality and making it a blatant diatribe against the Jews and the unresponsive UN. Yet the novel is essentially about love – love between a farmer and his land, a mother and her children, between lovers and friends. Whilst the novel is written according to Anglo-American conventions, the poetic prose that gives the book its Arabic edge resonates throughout. It is this blend of fact and fiction that is one of the novel’s strengths; like Amal, and indeed Abulhawa who was born to Palestinian refugees and later moved to the USA, this novel is a hybrid, caught as it is between two worlds.
Mornings in Jenin is a discomforting read, but as it is based on real events and told with such passion and conviction, it is well worth the heartache.